2k Clinical Consulting, Inc.

All About Protocol Deviations

The protocol for a clinical trial describes the entire study in detail, including the operational details of how it should be carried out. The purpose of the study protocol is to protect the health and safety of study participants while also proving efficacy of the product; however, when tasks are done outside the protocol, deviations are required.

What is a Protocol Deviation?

A protocol deviation happens when the activities of a researcher deviate from the Institutional Review Board-approved protocol without having severe implications, such as missing a visit window because the participant is travelling. It’s not as bad as a protocol violation which is a deviation from protocol that materially:

  • Decreases the quality or integrity of the information,
  • Causes the Informed Consent Form to be erroneous, or
  • Has an impact on the safety, rights, or wellbeing of a participant.

How Protocol Deviations Fit in a QMS

Some examples of protocol deviations occurring are:

  • Enrolling ineligible subjects
  • Lack of re-consenting subjects after amended protocols
  • The consent is missing signatures from subjects.

When deviations occur, the handling and resolution is intertwined in the QMS to ensure inspection readiness.  The organization could have a brainstorming session to discuss the deviation’s potential causes and effects in addition to what steps will be taken to prevent or mitigate the risk. These mitigations can then be monitored and reviewed on a regular basis, with specified thresholds for when a problem with trial registration becomes a substantial problem.

Important vs Non-Important Deviations

Once a procedure deviation has been found, it can be classified as either important or not important. Important protocol deviations can be defined using risk-based methodologies from ICH E6 R2.

Important protocol deviations are defined as subsets of protocol deviations that have the potential to have a major influence on the completeness, correctness, or reliability of essential study data, as well as a subject’s rights, safety, or well-being. Important protocol deviations, for example, could include enrolling individuals who do not meet critical eligibility criteria or neglecting to collect data needed to interpret primary endpoints, both of which could jeopardize the trial’s academic validity.

The International Conference on Harmonization (ICH) does not have a clear definition of a non-important protocol variation. As a result, if a procedure deviation does not match the requirements for being vital, it is considered non-important. Important and minor protocol deviations are both gathered, processed, and reported, albeit the processes may differ.

Conclusion

The cornerstone of a well-executed clinical trial is a well-thought-out and thorough protocol. Attend all sponsor-related meetings linked with the clinical study as the lead investigator. If you have any questions about the protocol or any study-related documentation, you should ask them right away to avoid any problems later. Finally, review the study, visit schedule and make plans ahead of time to prevent deviations.  

Struggling with minimizing protocol deviations for your site or department?  We’d love to hear from you to discuss strategies!

 

 

 

 

 

Steps on Implementing a Clinical QMS

By Afifa F. – 2K Clinical Consulting, Inc. 

 There is a popular saying in quality management that if you do not have the process written down, then it probably didn’t happen. Just like any other business, Clinical trials must have a management system as well. This needs to be well-conceived  as well as systemized.  

 What is a QMS in Clinical Setup? 

QMS are standardized procedures with guidelines. These particular guidelines are the backbone for all procedures to be carried out. A clinical quality management system (CQMS) is meant to keep track of all the records, activities, tasks, processes, important events, interactions, inspections, and training that must be administered and controlled during the study’s lifespan.. 

 What are the Benefits of QMS in a Clinical Trial? 

The Clinical Quality Management System program provides improved patient safety by enhancing quality, ensuring data security, reducing clinical trial bottlenecks, and bringing products to the market faster. 

 QMS Implementation Steps 

The following steps must be covered to effectively implement Clinical QMS: 

  1.  Mapping and Defining Your Process  – The production of process maps will compel the associated clinical trial members to visualize and define its processes. They will determine the connection pattern of those operations to be carried out during the process. Process maps are essential for determining who is responsible. Lastly, they help to clarify the flow of the clinical trials execution. 
  2.  Defining the Clinical Trials Quality Policy – Objectives are required in all quality management systems. Each employee must recognize the impact they have on quality. Your quality policy influences your quality objectives. It’s quantifiable and implemented across all the project team members involved in the clinical trials process.    The goal could be in the form of key success criteria. This aids an organization in stressing the path to its mission’s fulfilment. These performance-based indicators provide a metric for determining whether or not the organization is meeting its goals. 
  3. Developing Scale to Track Critical Success Factor – Scales and measurements keep track of progress once important success criteria are defined. This can be accomplished using a data reporting technique that collects specified information. Leaders should be informed of the information that has been processed. The purpose of the method is to improve the customer satisfaction index score. There must be a goal and a metric for determining whether or not that objective has been met. 
  4. Defining Defects for Each ProcessNon-conformances occur as a result of a flaw in the product or a flaw in the process. It is necessary to measure and repair any problem that occurs. This can be done by determining what has to be done to fix the problem.
  5. Documenting and Keeping RecordsQMS includes keeping record of information in the form of documents. The golden tip is to start from a less hefty documentation and move onto the more important ones. 
  6. Defining the Process QualityInternal audits, management reviews, corrective and preventive action processes, and communication channels are all part of your quality assurance approach. 
  7. Understanding the Trainings to be IncludedEveryone must demonstrate competence in the job. Training is simply the beginning and can take place on the job, in a classroom, or virtually. Internal auditor competency and CAPA training are two significant training areas. 
  8. Using the QMSUsing the QMS ensures that the highest quality product is produced. The procedure entails gathering non-conformances and their records, auditing data in accordance with the corrective and prevention plan and reviewing data in accordance with the Failure Mode Effective Analysis (FMEA) to be prepared for any concerns.
  9. Measuring, Monitoring and Implementation of Plans to Improve Output – Using a quality management system entails gathering data and analyzing it to see if it is fit for purpose and can produce the desired results. You will have to keep track of objectives and define new metrics for performance. You must have a keen eye for details by recognizing trends, patterns, and correlation. After identifying trends, you and your team must prepare for arranging new objectives, plan prospects that will help you reach these new goals and must keep the mindset of “maintaining the quality”.  

 Key Takeaway 

In order to provide quality data and a clinical trial that is inspection-ready, a clinical QMS must be implemented. By doing so, you will be able to obtain and retain accreditation, which will be necessary both locally and internationally. 

Key Aspects of an Inspection Ready TMF

Having a complete Trial Master File (TMF) is the highest priority for sponsors in terms of providing an accurate picture of the affiliated clinical trial.   This article speaks about key aspects and techniques to implement in order to have an inspection-ready TMF.

Key Aspects of an inspection ready Trial Master File

   Important aspects of having an inspection-ready TMF is to:

      ✓ Include documentation which is able to ‘tell the story’ of the trial.

      ✓ Contain a detailed time period, coexistent in time of facts and observation.

      ✓ Have an electronic source which documents are clearly stated.

     ✓ Update regularly and  implement proper Quality Check (QC) techniques.

QC techniques

Five QC techniques to implement to ensure an inspection-ready TMF are to:

  1. Look through the auditors eyes – Reviews are made from the source of information provided. Research requirements and expectations of health authorities in order to properly look at the data from an auditor’s perspective.
  2. Collect Information-All documentation from Core and Country levels such as the Protocols, Investigational Plans, Informed Consents, etc. should be thoroughly reviewed as the foundation QC’ing data from local site documentation.
  3. Site Sampling – Site Sampling is being able to look into all records based on a sample taken from a number of high enrollers, noncompliant and terminated sites.
  4. Review and Cross Check – Reviews are taken on bother paper and electronic Trial Master File. Each has different mode by which it is reviewed:

            For Paper files, review and cross check:

  •      Original hardcopies– all original documents must be properly checked if they are correct and signed accurately.
  •      Filing & Organization – ensure that there are no missing or misfiled files that can cause delays during an audit or inspection.

          For an electronic TMF, review and cross check:

  •       eTMF Study Access – review current project team list to verify correct access to study files
  •       eTMF Filing & Organization – Check for duplicates and errors in Indexing (or naming) and uploads
  1. Follow up to Resolution –  It is imperative to follow up all issues to resolution which means having an effective the root cause and all other corrective and preventive actions in place, including steps on how any investigation should be taken, and who should be involved and the process.

Overall, it is critical to be knowledgeable about key aspects of industry standards and regulations.  An inspection ready TMF takes proper planning, as noted in our article Planning for TMF Success, and effective QC measures as discussed in the following Trial Master File training sessions:

The “Audit-Ready” TMF: Concepts & Strategies (basic)
The “Audit-Ready” TMF: Tools &Techniques to effective QC Reviews (intermediate)- COMING SOON
The TMF Challenge: Part of the IRS (Inspection Readiness Survival) Series (advanced)-COMING SOON

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

3 Surefire Ways your TMF can extend your Inspection

The Trial Master File (TMF) is the backbone of the clinical trial. It consists of essential documents which not only enable the conduct of a clinical trial, but also enable the evaluation of the quality of data produced.

One of the questions asked at the beginning of an inspection is: “Where and how are your documents stored?”.  It is expected that all responsible parties know the location(s) of all paper/hybrid, and electronic documents that comprise the TMF.  Most importantly, it is expected that the TMF is readily accessible and audit-ready.

The reality is…this is not always the case.  In most cases, the TMF is often forgotten and becomes a disorganized “pile of files”.  As a result, inspections can be extended for this reason.

In fact, MHRA stated that that 35% of inspections were extended and required extra days particularly due to critical findings of TMFs.

Three (3) critical findings and surefire ways a TMF can extend your inspection are:

1. Lack of Access – The majority of time, the full TMF is not readily available or accessible to inspectors causing a delay in document review.

2. Poor Indexing – Oftentimes, the person designated to the TMF has issues locating documents during inspections due to poor indexing.

3. Incomplete/Missing Files – This is self-explanatory. Files that are inaccurate, incomplete or missing/misfiled can certainly cause a delay. Furthermore, uploading last minute documents to the eTMF (electronic Trial Master File) is a red flag as inspectors can see the download date and time of each document.

Sounds familiar?

Well, this can all be prevented with proper planning, as noted in our article Planning for TMF Success, and effective QC measures as discussed in the following Trial Master File training sessions:

The “Audit-Ready” TMF: Concepts & Strategies (basic)
The “Audit-Ready” TMF: Tools &Techniques to effective QC Reviews (intermediate)- COMING SOON
The TMF Challenge: Part of the IRS (Inspection Readiness Survival) Series (advanced)-COMING SOON